Authors: Bentley, Caitlin M.; Chib, Arul; Poveda, Sammia
Abstract: Openness has become an important, all‐encompassing term denoting activities faci ...
Expand
Abstract: Openness has become an important, all‐encompassing term denoting activities facilitated by sharing, using, producing, and redistributing information and communication resources within digital information systems. We compare theoretical advancements that emphasize processes and characteristics of openness with the limitations of extant approaches that have largely focused on improvements to productivity and efficiency. Based on Foucault and Bruner's ideas, this paper contributes a new critical narrative approach to understanding openness explicitly focused on structural transformation and power. The analysis focuses on the case of open development, examining 20 key studies based primarily on developing countries. The critical narrative approach unpacked the production of power/knowledge across actors, intentions, and outcomes of openness research and practice. We find that discursive formations are reliant on technocentric and normative ideals of researchers, leading to narratives of hypothetical outcomes that exclude marginalized perspectives. We propose hermeneutic composability and contesting normative narratives of openness as analytical techniques for an integrated, mutually constitutive conception of interactions between individuals, open artefacts, and open social praxis.
Collapse
Semantic filters:
critical narrative approach
Topics:
open source productivity digital innovation search engine database system
Methods:
critical narrative approach literature sample qualitative content analysis theory development cross sectional research
Abstract: The goal of this special issue on "Critical perspectives on information systems ...
Expand
Abstract: The goal of this special issue on "Critical perspectives on information systems and openness: Emerging discourses, meanings, models, and implications" is to advance a critical debate in Information Systems research on the theme of openness. Research in information systems on openness has focused on the nature of technology and how openness contributes to the development of new opportunities for technological and institutional enhancements even as it introduces various limitations. However, more often than not, we take for granted the positive potential of openness guided by a market-driven focus, which tends to marginalize potential distortions understood through interpretive, critical, and contextualized social theoretical positions. The aim of this special issue is to move beyond positivist and functionalist approaches, which merely promote rhetoric and hype, and critically and interpretively explore and explain the nature of openness and its enabling and constraining role in our pursuit for technological and institutional innovations. The aim of this special issue is thus to offer a venue for the critical study of the phenomenon of openness and its impact on people, organizations, and societies.The promises of openness are many, including its economic potential to generate innovations contributing to new industries, enhance transparency, accountability, and democratic processes of citizen participation in governance. Another oft discussed promise of openness concerns raising the accountability and transparency of State processes leading to more evolved democracy. Openness is not a monolithic concept, but is associated with various paradigms and practices which keeps our understanding of the phenomenon in flux, constantly being negotiated and contested, and influencing meanings of core associated concepts of communities and participation.Openness can potentially give rise to many paradoxes. For example, generating innovations may require openness for collaboration among industrial actors, while the commercialization of the innovation may raise the contrary need to enhance protection by limiting openness. Open international production may weaken local economies and domestic jobs, but at the same time potentially improve the export performance of a country. While open education may significantly empower students at the fringes of society, it may also reconfigure educational institutions to adopt market-driven strategies that arguably could undermine traditional educational values. Furthermore, while open government data is critical for transparency and accountability, it may strike back on a failing regime.Openness has various dimensions, such as relating to global public goods, software, data, standards, infrastructure, governance processes, content, access, and various others. These dimensions will have different implications in varying domains, for example, transparency may be of primary interest in discussing government processes, while open public facing data is most important in discussing response to public health epidemics. These different dimensions of openness may interact and create effects that can both create synergy in certain settings, yet also may undermine each other in other settings. For example, in the quest for enhancing open data, we may lose attention to the software aspect, and could justify the use of proprietary rather than open software. The increasing attention on open publishing has given rise to large numbers of open journals, with both positive and negative implications for academia and research.Our summary of the concept of openness emphasizes a number of issues. Firstly, it means different things to different stakeholder groups, and these meanings are situated, contested, negotiated, and evolving. Secondly, /journal/isj 763 766 EDITORIAL in developing countries. He has then analysed various distortions in the form of "policy-practice gaps" in the form of knowledge, governance, procurement, capacity, and finance. Building strategies to address these gaps then can help provide a road map on how to progress in meeting the normative goals of openness.
Collapse
Semantic filters:
critical narrative approach
Topics:
healthcare data public good innovation management crowdsourcing
Methods:
mixed method critical narrative approach literature sample
